Where Can I Buy Rum Raisin Ice Cream

Hey there, fellow ice cream enthusiasts and connoisseurs of all things delicious! Are you currently experiencing a serious craving for that glorious, boozy-sweet, fruity delight that is rum raisin ice cream? Yeah, me too. It’s like a little trip down memory lane with every spoonful, isn't it? That perfect blend of creamy vanilla, plump, rum-soaked raisins, and that subtle kick of… well, rum!
So, the big question on everyone's lips (or rather, in everyone's rumbling tummies) is: Where can I get my hands on some of this heavenly goodness? Don't you worry your pretty little head about it, because we’re about to embark on a frosty adventure to uncover the best places to snag yourself a pint (or a gallon, no judgment here!) of this classic flavor.
Let’s be honest, rum raisin isn't always front and center in every freezer aisle. It's not quite as ubiquitous as vanilla bean or chocolate chip, and sometimes it feels like you have to be in on a secret to find it. But fear not, my friends, because it's out there, waiting to be discovered!
Think of it as a treasure hunt, but the treasure is creamy, delicious ice cream. And the only thing you’ll need is your appetite and maybe a comfortable pair of walking shoes for those store-hopping expeditions.
The Usual Suspects: Grocery Stores Galore!
Alright, let’s start with the most obvious place to look. Your friendly neighborhood grocery store. These are often your best bet for finding a good variety of ice cream brands, and while rum raisin might not be on every shelf, it's definitely a common enough flavor that many popular brands will carry it.
You’ll want to hit up the freezer aisle and do a little reconnaissance. Scan those rows of frosty delights. Sometimes, it’s hiding behind a more popular flavor, or tucked away on a less prominent shelf. Keep your eyes peeled!
Big supermarket chains are usually a safe bet. Think places like Kroger, Safeway, Publix, Whole Foods, Trader Joe's – you get the picture. These stores tend to carry a wider selection of brands, and they often have both mainstream and more artisanal options.
Brands to keep an eye out for include Häagen-Dazs, Breyers, Ben & Jerry’s (though they might have their own unique twist on it!), and even some store-brand options can be surprisingly good. Don’t underestimate the power of a well-made store brand – they can often rival the big names!
Pro tip: If you have a favorite brand that usually has rum raisin but you can’t find it, check their website! Many brands list their available flavors and even have a store locator to help you find where their ice cream is sold near you. It’s like having a personal ice cream detective at your service!
And let’s not forget about the smaller, local grocery stores. Sometimes, these gems have a surprisingly curated selection of unique flavors that the bigger chains miss. So, if you pass by a charming little market, pop in and see if they’ve got your rum raisin fix!

Artisanal Delights: The Cream of the Crop
Now, if you're looking for something a little more special, something that whispers sweet nothings of quality ingredients and unique flavor profiles, then it’s time to explore the world of artisanal ice cream shops. These are the places where ice cream dreams are made!
Artisanal ice cream makers often take classic flavors and give them a delightful, gourmet twist. They might use locally sourced dairy, infuse their rum with unique spices, or source particularly plump and flavorful raisins. The result? Ice cream that’s not just a treat, but an experience.
How to find these magical places? A quick online search for "artisanal ice cream near me" or "gourmet ice cream [your city]" should do the trick. Websites like Yelp, Google Maps, or even local food blogs can be your best friends in this quest.
What to expect? Be prepared for potentially higher price points, but trust me, it’s usually worth it. You’re paying for the craft, the quality, and the sheer joy of tasting something truly exceptional. And who knows, you might discover your new favorite ice cream shop!
Some of these shops might even have rum raisin on their rotating flavor menu. This is where those “seasonal” or “limited edition” flavors come into play. So, keep an eye on their social media pages or websites for flavor updates. You wouldn’t want to miss out on a fresh batch of perfection, would you?
And hey, even if they don’t have rum raisin today, you can always ask! A polite "Do you ever make rum raisin?" might just plant the seed for a future flavor creation. You could be the inspiration behind their next amazing batch!
Online Orders: Bringing the Frosty Goodness Home
In today’s digital age, almost anything can be delivered right to your doorstep, and yes, that includes ice cream! For those who are truly dedicated to their rum raisin habit, or if you live in an area with limited options, ordering online can be a game-changer.

Several online retailers specialize in gourmet and artisanal ice creams, and they often ship nationwide. These companies understand the delicate nature of ice cream and use insulated packaging and dry ice to ensure your frozen treasure arrives in pristine condition.
Websites to explore include companies like Goldbelly, which partners with famous ice cream shops across the country, allowing you to order their specialties. You might also find smaller, independent ice cream makers who have their own online stores.
Be prepared for shipping costs, as they can add up. However, if you’re ordering a few pints or planning a special occasion, it can definitely be worth it. Plus, the convenience of not having to leave your couch is pretty darn appealing, wouldn’t you agree?
Things to consider when ordering online:
- Shipping fees: As mentioned, these can be significant.
- Minimum order quantities: Some sites require a minimum purchase.
- Delivery windows: Make sure you’re home to receive your ice cream so it doesn't melt into a sweet, sad puddle.
- Reviews: Check customer reviews to get an idea of the company’s shipping reliability and product quality.
It’s like Christmas morning, but instead of presents, you get a cooler full of deliciousness! Imagine the excitement of opening that box and seeing your beloved rum raisin ice cream ready to be devoured.
Making Your Own: The Ultimate DIY Adventure
Okay, okay, I know. This one requires a little more effort, but hear me out! If you’re a true rum raisin aficionado, there’s a certain satisfaction that comes with making your own. Plus, you get to control every single aspect of your ice cream creation.
Want more rum? Go for it! Want extra plump raisins? You got it! Want to add a sprinkle of nutmeg? Why not!

There are tons of easy-to-follow recipes online for homemade rum raisin ice cream. Many don't even require an ice cream maker anymore! You can find no-churn recipes that are surprisingly simple and yield fantastic results.
Ingredients you’ll typically need:
- Heavy cream
- Sweetened condensed milk (for no-churn)
- Vanilla extract
- Your favorite raisins
- Rum (the better the rum, the better the flavor!)
The key to great rum raisin ice cream is to properly plump up those raisins. This usually involves soaking them in rum (or even a mixture of rum and water) for a few hours, or even overnight. This rehydrates them and infuses them with that wonderful boozy flavor.
Then, you simply mix your ice cream base, fold in your rum-soaked raisins, and freeze. If you have an ice cream maker, follow its instructions. If not, there are methods involving freezing and stirring at intervals. It's a bit more hands-on, but the reward is a batch of pure, unadulterated rum raisin bliss, made exactly to your liking.
And think of the bragging rights! "Oh, this old thing? I just whipped it up myself." You'll be the undisputed hero of every potluck and dessert night. Plus, the aroma of rum-soaked raisins permeating your kitchen is pretty darn wonderful.
Don't Forget the Local Scoop Shops!
Beyond the big chains and the artisanal destinations, there are those beloved local ice cream parlors. These are the places that have been serving up scoops of happiness for generations, and they often have a signature flavor or two that keeps people coming back.
Many of these parlors will have a rotating selection of classic flavors, and rum raisin is a beloved staple for a reason. It’s that comforting, familiar taste that many people grew up with.

How to find them? Again, a good old internet search is your friend. Look for "ice cream shop [your town]" or "local dairy bar." You can also ask around! Neighbors, friends, coworkers – someone is bound to know about the best local ice cream spot.
Visiting a local scoop shop is more than just buying ice cream; it’s about supporting your community and enjoying a nostalgic experience. The friendly faces behind the counter, the smell of waffle cones, the buzzing atmosphere – it all adds to the deliciousness.
And if they happen to have rum raisin, consider it a sign! It’s a flavor that deserves to be celebrated at these cherished establishments.
A Final Word of Encouragement (and Maybe a Little More Rum Raisin Talk)
So, you see, my dear rum raisin adventurer, finding this delightful flavor is not an impossible mission. It might take a little searching, a little exploring, and maybe even a bit of online ordering, but the reward is oh-so-sweet.
Whether you’re picking up a pint from your local grocery store, indulging in a gourmet creation from an artisanal shop, ordering a special delivery, or even embarking on a DIY ice cream adventure, the pursuit of rum raisin is a journey worth taking.
Remember to embrace the process. Each place you check, each flavor you discover, is a step closer to that perfect, creamy, rum-kissed scoop. And when you finally find it, take a moment. Close your eyes. Savor that burst of flavor. Appreciate the subtle warmth of the rum, the delightful chew of the raisins, and the pure, unadulterated joy of a truly classic ice cream.
And hey, if all else fails, just remember: a little bit of rum, some raisins, and some good quality vanilla ice cream can work wonders. You can always make your own impromptu rum raisin experience! 😉
So go forth, my friends! Let your taste buds guide you. And may your rum raisin ice cream dreams always come true. Happy scooping!
